Key takeaways
- Work area: ranges from a compact portable footprint on the F-series up to a large bed on the P2S, which matters for anyone cutting full sheets rather than small parts.
- Enclosure and safety rating: fully enclosed machines like the S1 carry a Class 1 safety rating, which the maker lists as safe to run without separate laser safety glasses; open-frame machines need protective eyewear and a clear workspace.
- Power output: diode wattage and CO2 tube wattage both affect cut depth and pass count; reviewers note that a higher-wattage diode model cuts thicker material in a single pass, reducing the smoke and edge charring that comes from multiple passes.
- Ventilation needs: CO2 machines and higher-power diode machines both benefit from an exhaust hose routed outside, even when enclosed, since fumes still build up inside the chamber during longer cuts.
A beginner who wants one machine that engraves and cuts wood, leather, and acrylic without extra ventilation hassle fits best with the enclosed diode S1, a crafter who needs speed for metal tumblers and jewelry should look at the dual-laser F1 Ultra, and anyone cutting large acrylic or hardwood panels regularly needs the CO2-powered P2S instead of a diode machine. xTool’s lineup splits cleanly into diode, infrared/fiber, and CO2 families, and picking the right family matters more than picking a specific model number.
Understanding xTool’s Three Laser Families
xTool builds three distinct laser types, and each is good at different materials. Diode lasers (the S1, D1-series, and M1-series) are the most affordable and handle engraving and cutting on wood, leather, dark acrylic, and coated metal. Infrared and fiber machines (the F1 and F2 families) add a second laser source tuned for marking bare metal and some plastics at high speed, which diode light cannot mark well. CO2 machines (the P2S and P3) use a sealed gas tube that cuts and engraves non-metal material, especially clear acrylic and glass, more cleanly and at thicker depths than diode lasers can manage.
- Work area: ranges from a compact portable footprint on the F-series up to a large bed on the P2S, which matters for anyone cutting full sheets rather than small parts.
- Enclosure and safety rating: fully enclosed machines like the S1 carry a Class 1 safety rating, which the maker lists as safe to run without separate laser safety glasses; open-frame machines need protective eyewear and a clear workspace.
- Power output: diode wattage and CO2 tube wattage both affect cut depth and pass count; reviewers note that a higher-wattage diode model cuts thicker material in a single pass, reducing the smoke and edge charring that comes from multiple passes.
- Ventilation needs: CO2 machines and higher-power diode machines both benefit from an exhaust hose routed outside, even when enclosed, since fumes still build up inside the chamber during longer cuts.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Model Family | Best For | Key Stated Specs | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| xTool S1 (enclosed diode) | Beginners wanting engraving plus cutting in one safe, enclosed unit | The maker lists 20W and 40W diode configurations, an optional infrared module, and a work area close to 20 x 12.5 inches with a Class 1 enclosed rating | Diode lasers struggle with clear acrylic and bare uncoated metal |
| xTool P2S (CO2 cutter) | Large-format cutting of acrylic, wood, and glass | The maker lists a 55W CO2 tube rated for cutting acrylic and hardwood panels in a single pass on a roomier bed | Larger footprint, needs a dedicated exhaust setup, and does not mark bare metal well |
| xTool F1 Ultra (dual infrared and diode) | Fast metal marking plus portable craft work | The maker lists a combined fiber and diode laser source with engraving speeds reported by reviewers as among the fastest in the desktop class | Smaller work area than the S1 or P2S; best suited to small parts rather than sheet material |
| xTool D1 Pro (open-frame diode, prior generation) | Budget-focused makers comfortable adding their own enclosure | Open-frame diode design with a straightforward frame and moderate work area | No built-in enclosure, so eye protection and a clear workspace are required; largely superseded by the S1 for new buyers |
| xTool M1 Ultra (hybrid blade and laser) | Crafters who also need a vinyl or paper cutting blade alongside a laser | Combines a laser module with a swappable blade cutting head in one enclosed unit | Smaller bed size limits it to craft-scale projects rather than larger panels |
How the Diode, Fiber, and CO2 Trade-Offs Play Out in Practice
Reviewers consistently report that the single biggest mismatch new buyers make is choosing a diode machine and then discovering it cannot cleanly cut clear acrylic or engrave bare steel. A diode laser is reflected or barely absorbed by clear and light-colored material, so results on those surfaces are inconsistent regardless of settings. Anyone whose project list includes clear acrylic signage, glass etching, or stainless steel marking should budget for either a CO2 machine or an infrared/fiber unit rather than trying to force a diode laser to do that work.
On the other hand, diode machines remain the most cost-effective choice for the most common hobbyist materials: wood, leather, cardboard, dark or anodized acrylic, and coated metal tumblers. The S1’s enclosed design is also a meaningful safety upgrade over open-frame diode machines, since it contains both the laser light and most of the smoke and particulate generated during a cut.
Pick This If…
| Situation | Recommended Model Family |
|---|---|
| You want one safe, enclosed machine for most craft materials | xTool S1 |
| You regularly cut full sheets of acrylic, plywood, or glass | xTool P2S |
| You sell personalized metal tumblers or jewelry and need speed | xTool F1 Ultra |
| You want a laser and a vinyl/paper cutting blade in one footprint | xTool M1 Ultra |
| Budget is the top priority and you can manage your own enclosure | A prior-generation open-frame diode model, bought with eyes open about the lack of enclosure |
Workspace, Ventilation, and Material Compatibility Notes
Every xTool machine, enclosed or not, should vent to the outdoors through a hose during operation; an enclosure contains stray light but does not eliminate the need for exhaust. Check ceiling or window clearance for the exhaust hose run before buying, since the P2S and larger diode beds often need a longer duct path than a small desktop setup allows. Material thickness matters too: a lower-wattage diode machine may need two or three passes to cut material that a higher-wattage unit or a CO2 tube cuts in one pass, and multiple passes increase edge charring on wood and leather. Always check the maker’s current compatibility notes for a specific material before committing a full sheet to a test cut.
Alternatives Worth Considering
Buyers who only need engraving, never cutting, might be better served by a lower-power dedicated engraving-only machine, which trades cutting ability for a lower cost and smaller footprint. Those who need to cut and engrave thick hardwood or dense materials at a larger scale sometimes step up to a CNC router instead of a laser, since routing handles material thickness that any desktop laser struggles with. Buyers focused purely on metal marking for industrial parts sometimes find a dedicated fiber marking machine from a different maker better suited to that single task than a dual-purpose hybrid unit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an xTool diode laser cut metal?
Diode lasers can mark some coated or anodized metal surfaces but cannot cleanly cut through metal. Marking bare or uncoated metal at high speed is better suited to the infrared and fiber laser models in xTool’s F-series.
What is the difference between the S1 and the P2S?
The S1 is a diode laser suited to wood, leather, and coated materials in an enclosed, portable footprint, while the P2S uses a CO2 tube that the maker lists as capable of cutting thicker acrylic and hardwood in a single pass on a larger bed. The P2S is the better choice for anyone who regularly works with clear acrylic or glass.
Do I need laser safety glasses with an enclosed xTool machine?
Enclosed machines carrying a Class 1 rating are designed to contain the laser light during normal operation, which the maker states removes the need for separate eyewear in typical use. Open-frame diode models still require protective glasses rated for the laser’s wavelength whenever the machine is running.
How much ventilation does an xTool machine actually need?
Every model benefits from an exhaust hose routed to an exterior window or vent, since fumes and fine particulate build up inside the work chamber even on enclosed machines. Running a laser in a closed room without any exhaust is not recommended regardless of which model is used.
Is the xTool F1 Ultra worth it over the original F1?
The original F1 has largely been phased out in favor of the F1 Ultra, which reviewers describe as combining fiber and diode laser sources for both metal and non-metal work at notably higher engraving speeds. Buyers who find an original F1 listed as refurbished should weigh the lower cost against the newer model’s broader material range and speed.
Which xTool model is best for a total beginner?
The enclosed S1 is the model most reviewers point beginners toward, since its Class 1 enclosure reduces the safety setup required and its diode laser covers the widest range of common hobby materials. Buyers should still plan for an exhaust hose and a dedicated, clear workspace regardless of which enclosed model they choose.
You might also like